It's a 'figure it out what works for you, yourself' matter. Some have better defense-to-weight ratios than others, but others grant more stats of different kinds like resistances, or lower overall defense yet superior individual defenses (e.g. It's the same with what you're classifying 'medium/light' armor. Ornstein's set has very poor stats in every respect, but provides THE most Lightning Defense.
Other sets, such as fully upgraded Black Iron, or Smough's Set (which cannot be upgraded) have superior defense, but offer less Poise.
NONE of them are 'the best' because NONE of them have superior of ANYTHING! Havel's Set, for example, is the heaviest set, but does NOT offer the best defense however, it's unrivaled in Poise. Another.ĭifferent attack speeds, attack animations, damage statistics and outputs, etc etc etc. There is no 'the best' of ANY weapon.Įach. There is no 'the best' of what you call 'medium' armor. All the gear caters to different situations, different builds, different styles of different players.
Seriously, there's SEVERAL threads where myself and others have pointed out that NOTHING is 'the best' in its 'class', weapon or armor. And which weapon (no katana) is consider the best in the different types?There is none.